🔗 Share this article

In the same way that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west, supporters of the pop phenomenon will heed the summons for latest releases. Well before the economy-lifting, industry-transforming worldwide success of the Eras concert series, Swift had nurtured a particularly deep and personal bond with her audience, also within the reverential world of mainstream music. Such a bond, upheld by hidden clues, long-running one-sided storylines and possibly her personal universe, could be authentic and remarkable and sustaining, a reliable vessel through difficult times – I have experienced it. Yet several years into her peak popularity, Swift’s regular supplying of her supporters is beginning to look not so much like a two-way dedication and more obviously profit-driven, the many one-off re-releases and exclusive records and limited-edition Target drops similar to a wealth levy on her dedicated fans.

The Most Recent Product

The newest installment is the Life of a Showgirl movie – or, to be precise, a “launch event” film for her latest record The Life of a Showgirl, releasing this week. Officially billed as the Album Launch Celebration of a Showgirl, it consists of song explainers, filming glimpses and one music video (repeated once), casually compiled into one 90-minute sitting. This is the kind of material any other artist would release online, but which Swift, following her proven cinematic success with her Eras Tour concert movie, chooses to release on the big screen this weekend. Forecasting substantial earnings across America, it is expected to become the highest-grossing film this week – unfortunately, considering it barely qualifies as a supplementary piece to the album, not to mention one worthy of note in her broad collection of releases.

Cinematic Experience

As a cinema experience, The Premiere Film for Showgirl does reflect the record it promotes – rote, tinnily light, featuring uninspired production and unpolished feel of someone rushing to finish. More indication of according to cultural analysis has termed Swift’s burnout era. In a low-fi intro recorded facing the lens, Swift, modestly self-conscious and modest as usual, describes the film as “sort of a journey of the origins of the tracks” representing a thrilling, exciting period”.

But save for a behind-the-scenes featurette on the Ophelia video spliced into brief parts, the film mainly consists of clips that show song words accompanied by a clip from the related production on loop. That’s fine for background viewing in a social setting, but a problem as the main event for a record that is ideal as background music, its mild musical style and hall-of-fame cringe lyrics allowed to wash over you in one unread flush. Maybe alcohol helps; other than one holler for the remarkably unaware that particular song, there was silence at the early family viewing.

Song Commentary

She includes each musical piece with a short explanation of her creative approach – generally appreciated, even critics can claim it's boring – however, they mostly consist of broad statements, professed enthusiasm and avoiding controversy (yes, she got permission from the copyright holders to sample that particular track). The artist often avoids specifics about songs with clear subjects, but the ambiguity in this case feels especially pointless. There is no mention of the album’s muse, her partner, though she has been unusually open about their domestic bliss during press tours lately. The frequently analyzed and poorly judged Charli xcx diss in that particular track is presented as “a love letter to someone who hates you”. (Interestingly, a biting “attention is affection and an abundance from you, increases the discomfort.) The passionate, double-entendre-laden Wood, including a symbolic reference, is promoted as a track regarding beliefs accompanied by a family-friendly, suggestive look to the camera.

Relatability and Narration

Swift somehow remains adept at implying connection despite her fame in pop music; her conversational and interesting guide, even if sometimes misleading on her own music. (This is not the album of bangers as promoted in other media.) That especially shines during professional moments; the standout scenes, without doubt, happen as she allows focus to her creative partners – one contributor, the movement designer, and the cinematographer, among others – and to the taut metronome of video production. These insider views – a moment of remote work, jokes with her dancers, improving a shot – remain as compelling as they are short and suggestive. They reveal both the community and the operation supporting her brand, the actual core of performer existence.

Overall Assessment

Perhaps assembling more, in a way both strategic and revealing, was an order too tall for her demanding timeline of diminishing returns. And perhaps diehard fans of the release – acknowledging their presence – may discover value in this minimal offering of Target treats meaningful. Yet achieving financial success with minimal effort does not constitute a musical achievement. It becomes one more profitable item in her empire.

• The artist: The Premiere Event of a Showgirl is out in cinemas now